Buy an Investment Property Now or Wait? What to Consider

March 20, 2024

Owning an investment property is a great way to increase your income and build financial stability over the long term. But knowing when to make the leap from owning property to also managing additional property is challenging. We’ve gathered information to help you decide whether investing in a rental property is right for you.

Current Housing Market

It's important to consider current market data when deciding if now is a good time to purchase an investment property. Let's look at the numbers here in Kitsap County, Washington. While the number of sales was down last quarter, the average sale price rose to $665,000. And despite higher than average interest rates, home sellers overall still received 96 percent of their asking price. These numbers indicate that the housing market here remains strong. And remember, $665,000 was the average sale price in Kitsap County, an area with a lot of different types of properties. This includes everything from high-end waterfront homes on Bainbridge Island to small condos in Bremerton, and everything in between. With so much variety, it’s possible to find a second property that meets your financial budget and investment needs.

Current Rental Market

Kitsap County's rental market remains healthy. We gathered data using the 700+ rental properties we manage here at Windermere Property Management. The following rental rates are the average for a 3-bedroom, 2-bath single-family home:

  • Bainbridge Island: $3,200 per month
  • Bremerton: $2,319 per month
  • Hansville: $2,100 per month
  • Kingston/Indianola: $2,600 per month
  • Port Orchard: $2,775 per month
  • Poulsbo: $2,800 per month
  • Silverdale: $2,813 per month


As you’re researching investment properties, keep these averages in mind. Take time to do a cost-benefit analysis of various properties with a mortgage calculator to ensure that rental rates will more than cover your monthly expenses. And remember, while interest rates are higher than average right now, as real estate experts often say, you marry the home, but date the rate. You can always refinance when the rates go down, which will allow you to make more on your rental property in the future. If you have specific financial questions, we recommend talking to Windermere’s partner at Penrith Loans. Penrith Branch Manager/Mortgage Consultant Cherie Kesti is an excellent local resource. She has over 20 years of experience in the home financing industry. 

Buy Now or Wait?

Based on Kitsap County’s real estate market and his local expertise, Cameron Tappe, thinks now is a good time to buy. Tappe is a former Windermere Realtor and one of our current Windermere Property Managers. "In Kitsap County, the demand for housing is on the rise, with nearly 1,500 new housing units needed each year to meet the growing needs of the community. Whether through purchasing income-generating properties, developing new housing units, or purchasing your first rental property, seizing this moment can pave the way for long-term wealth accumulation and financial security. With increasing demand for housing in Kitsap County, investing in real estate not only makes financial sense but also contributes to meeting the critical need for housing in our community," explains Tappe.

Managing Your Rental Property

If you do decide to move forward with purchasing a rental property, you’ll have to prepare it for future tenants. Then you’ll have to decide whether you want to be a landlord, which comes with many responsibilities. Being a landlord involves much more than simply renting. You must be familiar with local tenant laws and know how to manage renters. This includes screening tenants, drawing up a lease, setting a security deposit, collecting monthly payments, managing preventive maintenance, and fielding fix-it calls as needed. While not a full-time job, managing a rental property is a significant time commitment. If you have concerns about owning a rental property, this list of common misconceptions may help assuage your fears and help you better understand the benefits.

Utilizing a Full-Service Property Management Company

If managing a rental property sounds like too much to deal with, Windermere Property Management is available to help. A full-service property management company, we serve property owners and tenants throughout Kitsap County. Our staff takes care of handling all your rental management needs. This includes effectively marketing your property, correctly pricing rentals for our market, screening tenants, collecting payments through our tenant/owner online portal, resolving maintenance issues, and more.


We are also able to find and screen renters quickly. Our average turnover time for the rental properties we manage is 15 days. This is much faster than most individual landlords can achieve on their own and with a lot less stress. For more detailed information on how our trusted, locally-owned property management company can help, you can learn more on our website or contact us today.

Share this post


You May Also Like to Read

March 4, 2025
Rainy days in the Pacific Northwest aren't for everyone, but there are many ways to make them more enjoyable. And, as we head into spring, keep in mind that this darker rainy season is temporary. Soon, we'll have more daylight hours, and spring flowers will be blooming. Check out these ideas for making rainy days as fun as possible. Stay active Whether it’s joining a local gym, starting an at-home gym practice, or going for a walk despite the rain, staying active is essential for your mental and physical health during the rainy season. Also, nature is the Pacific Northwest’s playground. Many local trails have thick forests that provide shelter from the rain and shield you from the worst of it. Invest in proper clothing and gear Similarly, if being outside and staying active is your preferred activity method, don’t let the weather stop you. Investing in proper clothing, shoes, and gear can make almost any day an outside day. Many local stores, like Wildernest on Bainbridge Island and Flicka in Poulsbo, have waterproof jackets and shoes . Invest in a pair of warm wool socks to keep your feet dry. On really cold days, put a pair of warmers into your gloves or shoes. Talk to a doctor about options If you're new to the Pacific Northwest, consider talking to your doctor about other ways to help your body physically adapt to the winter weather and darkness that is unique to this area. They might recommend daily vitamin D supplements and a sun lamp . Sun lamps mimic natural light and can be effective for those with Seasonal Affective Disorder. Speak to your doctor before making any changes. Try boredom busters for kids Do you have kids who are starting to bounce off the walls or are (conversely) staying glued to their devices? Check out this list of fun boredom busters to break up the long days. Even a quick card or board game can put a spark of controlled energy into the room. There are also many local indoor play spaces to choose from in the area. There are play spaces for toddlers , indoor trampoline parks , laser tag venues , and arcades for teens. Lean into seasonal sports Enjoying a winter sport can mean everything from watching it live to watching it on TV to participating in it. Living so close to the Olympic Mountains and Mount Rainier means various options for skiing, snowboarding, tubing, snowshoeing, and more. In addition, for those looking to watch sports live in the winter, Seattle is home to many professional teams, as well as minor league and college teams. If you prefer to stay off the roads and in the comfort of your own home, invite a couple of friends over to watch a game together. Start a new hobby For many, the rainy days provide a little more time since there’s often less running around. You can use that extra time to pick up a new hobby. Perhaps you’d like to get on the sourdough bread bandwagon, pick up woodworking, or learn how to knit. Maybe you’ve never made a mosaic but want to give it a try. Whatever you choose, these slower days provide the perfect opportunity to give it a whirl. BARN (Bainbridge Artisan Resource Network) hosts a range of workshops in an incredible space. Be sure to check them out. Choose an indoor home project to complete Meanwhile, if you feel stuck at home and don’t feel like picking up a new hobby, then why not tidy up your home a bit? Since this is the time of year when you may find yourself at home more, think about doing something that will make it feel more inviting. Purge old clothes, household items, and toys no longer being used. Pick a room to reorganize or rearrange the furniture. Hang up the pictures that you’ve been meaning to get to, or re-paint your home office. Tackling and completing a home improvement project will create a great sense of accomplishment. Take the time to slow down On the other hand, many take rainy days as an opportunity to embrace a slower lifestyle. That could mean spending the day reading a book or finding a new series to binge-watch without feeling guilty. Perhaps you let yourself enjoy a cup of coffee or tea in the morning for a longer amount of time. Or, since it’s dark outside, go to bed earlier or sleep in on the weekends. Some call it wintering and fully accept the conditions of this season while remaining home. Embrace Scandinavian Hygge Concepts Faced with even worse weather challenges in the winter than those in the Pacific Northwest, many Scandinavian countries still top the world happiness charts. How do they do it? Explore the concept of Danish hygge and find ways to embrace it in your own life. Check out this list of 100 Ideas to Add Hygge Into Your Everyday Life . Candles, warm blankets and a favorite mug for hot drinks are just the tip of the iceberg to creating a life of hygge. Plan a future trip Having something to look forward to can help pass the time during long rainy stretches. Think of an activity or trip that you’d like to do in the future and start planning. It could be an overnight trip or your weeklong summer vacation. It can be a camping trip, a day at the spa, or an upcoming concert. If all else fails, plan next year’s vacation to somewhere warm during this time to escape the cold days. It doesn’t matter where you go, or when you go, or for how long. Simply put something on the calendar you’re looking forward to and start making it happen. We know the rainy season isn't for everyone. Keep in mind that longer, sunnier days are on the horizon. In the meantime, take advantage of some of these ideas to make the next few weeks (and future winters) not just bearable but enjoyable.
winter-activities-fun
February 1, 2025
Kitsap County and the surrounding area is home to fun winter activities for kids and adults. Here are some indoor and outdoor ideas.
elevate-rental-property-painting
January 7, 2025
If your rental property needs to be updated, here are 6 ideas that will increase the home's value and attract renters.
home-related-gifts-holidays
By 1917687 December 4, 2024
Shop small for the holidays with these unique, local gift ideas. Kitsap County has many memorable options for everyone on your list.
smart-home-technology
November 19, 2024
Smart home technology can be beneficial for your rental property. Find out which devices could benefit you and your tenants.
October 16, 2024
If your rental property needs repair work, here are some considerations before you decide to do it yourself or hire a contractor.
farm-local-kid-goat
September 30, 2024
From goat yoga to pumpkin patches, here are five great farms in Kitsap County to visit this fall.
Small-Spaces-Home-Kid-Bedroom
August 20, 2024
From a tiny bedroom to a small kitchen, here are tips to maximize the small spaces in your home and make them feel bigger.
organizations-kitsap-donations
July 25, 2024
Learn about 4 organizations that strengthen and enrich Kitsap County's community and how you can get involved.
fathers-day
June 5, 2024
Father's Day is coming up! Here are some fun ways to celebrate in Kitsap County and the surrounding area.
Show More
Share by: